Skip to main content

Parliament is Supreme - Part II


The Parliament today debated the Censure Motion Introduced by Shri Sharad Yadav and Smt. Sushma Swaraj, against the members of Team Anna, alleging that they acted in a manner, derogatory to the parliament and the members of parliament. All the parliamentarians spoke of the Sanctity of the Institution and the Privileges of the House and its members.
It was like a re-run of the debate of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Bill 2011, where whole house was busy in praising the institution of Parliament and stating that Parliament is Supreme. The whole drama unfolded and was reported in media as the bill was not passed in Rajya Sabha. The Government that day proved the Government is Supreme and the Parliament is probably having some identity crisis.
I would dare not say that the Parliament is not supreme, but, I will respectfully submit that the Members have by discussing such motions, and not standing up to the occasion when the time requires, have themselves deprived the institution of the sanctity.
The Members themselves also have done certain things that have harmed the sanctity of the institution. The members have given unnecessary stress on the words and statements of team Anna and have therefore even given more strength to their statements. It would have been better if some grace had been shown and after simply condemning the same the Parliament could have discussed some important issues disturbing the nation. This view was also shared by certain members in their speech on the issue in Loksabha today.
The members of Parliament are elected representatives and therefore it’s even more of their duty to be gracious with the sentiments of people. If some citizen of the country expresses anguish on the political scenario then it is more of the matter of self-introspection and not a matter of debate in the house. The debate on the censure motion has been reported in the media as Netas Vs Team Anna. This debate  in my view has in-fact given even more strength to the criticism of the MP’s by the members of Team Anna.
This also gives rise to one more issue. Whether we need a codified law with regards to the sanctity of the parliament and the Privileges of the Parliament?
There is no law codified which defines what are the privileges and sanctity of the institution of democracy?  What can be permitted? What cannot be permitted? Where the line is drawn between criticism and breach of privileges? Whether Truth can be a defense?
So there will always be confusion in the minds of the critics of the democratic institutions. They will never be sure that whether their criticism will go down well with the members sitting in there or not? I would humbly submit that the Parliament – as the fountainhead of the democracy in India needs to codify the law dealing with its own privileges.
And yes, if the unity that the MP’s showed today while discussing the privileges is shown while discussing the important issues concerning the people of the country, such embarrassing position will never arise.
May the wisdom prevail on one and all!!



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Education: A Key Driver of Social Change and Economic Development

Education is not just a means to acquire knowledge and skills, but a powerful tool that can transform individuals, communities, and societies. It can contribute to economic growth, social cohesion, and democratic governance. Education is a fundamental human right and a public good that should be accessible to all, regardless of their background or circumstances. However, despite its importance, education remains a contested and politicized issue in many parts of the world. Governments, civil society, the private sector, and other stakeholders have different views and interests in shaping education policies and practices. This has led to unequal access to education, poor quality of education, and inadequate resources for education. To address these challenges, public policymakers and politicians need to understand the importance of education in shaping the society they want to create and serve. They need to recognize that education is not a neutral or technical matter, but a complex...
Post a Comment
Read more

Save early to earn more

Save early to earn more Prabhakar Sinha | TNN Time is money, goes the saying, which holds true in almost all aspects of life. But, it is more so in case of savings. If you start saving early, by the time you retire, you will have enough money to lead a prosperous retired life. When you start saving early, your saved amount gets a longer time to earn returns. Take for example, if you start saving at the age of 25, or just at the time when you get your first salary, your savings of Rs 5,000 per month, at a conservative return of 10% per annum, will swell to Rs 1.91 crore in 35 years or by the time you retire at the age of 60. But, if you start saving late, say, at the age of 30, your saving of Rs 5,000 per month will become Rs 1.14 crore. If you start at 35, the amount will become only Rs 67 lakh. And, at the age of 35, even if you start saving double the amount i.e. Rs 10,000 per month, by the time of retirement, that will become only Rs 1.34 crore. This is called power...
Post a Comment
Read more

Meet with Saurabhee Winner of - INDIAN IDOL 4

Saurabhee.. Nirali.. Pratik.. ME(Punit) and Hardik 21/10/2009 11:00 PM Outside Ahmedabad Management Association... We Friends met at our hang out and got a chance to meet Saurabhee winner of Indian Idol 4. To a sweet surprise we got the chance to meet her because of my Friend Viraj's sister Nirali who was also participant of Indian Idol. We Group of Lawyer friends were impressed by her poise and humility. We literally Interviewed her and also asked her regarding her experience post winning Indian Idol. We also asked her about how she will compare her life before and after the Indian Idol 4. She was kind enough to answer our curious Quick Fires and also made us understand the issues attached to the stardom and we found her too humble and down to earth that she mixed up with us in a very short time and we didn’t feel like talking to some star. We also discussed some daily soaps running on TV Channels and the realities attached to reality shows. Impressed is what I will say after mee...
Post a Comment
Read more